If you’re considering reconnecting with someone after a period of estrangement, forgiveness can sometimes feel like part of the deal.
Perhaps they’ve apologised.
Perhaps they’ve acknowledged some of what happened.
Perhaps they’ve said they want to move forward.
And you may find yourself thinking:
“Do I have to accept their apology?”
“If they’ve said sorry, shouldn’t I forgive them?”
“Can we have a relationship again if I can’t forgive what happened?”
The answer isn’t necessarily yes.
You can choose to have a new relationship with someone without feeling that you have to forgive everything that happened in the past.
Reconciliation and forgiveness aren’t the same thing
Reconciliation is about the relationship between two people.
Forgiveness is something much more personal.
They don’t have to happen together.
You might decide that you would like to explore a relationship with someone again while still feeling hurt or angry about what happened.
You might be able to acknowledge an apology without feeling ready to forgive.
You might decide that some things can be left in the past without needing to resolve exactly how you feel about them.
And you might decide that you don’t want reconciliation at all.
There isn’t one correct emotional starting point.
An apology can matter without fixing everything
An apology can be meaningful.
Being acknowledged and hearing someone take responsibility can sometimes be an important part of rebuilding trust.
But saying sorry doesn’t automatically undo what happened.
It doesn’t necessarily remove the impact it had on you.
And it doesn’t mean that you have to immediately feel differently.
You may appreciate the apology and still need time.
You may accept that someone is genuinely sorry while remaining unsure about whether you want a relationship with them.
Or you may feel that the apology doesn’t fully reflect your experience.
All of those responses are possible.
You don’t have to accept an apology on someone else’s timeline
Sometimes there can be an unspoken expectation that once someone has apologised, the other person should accept the apology and move on.
But an apology is something one person offers.
What you do with it is your decision.
You don’t have to say:
“It’s okay.”
You don’t have to say:
“I forgive you.”
And you don’t have to immediately return to the relationship you had before.
This can be particularly important when past experiences have left you feeling traumatised.
Your mind may understand that someone is apologising while your thoughts, feelings or bodily reactions are telling you that you don’t yet feel safe.
That doesn’t mean you’re being difficult or refusing to move forward.
It may mean that your experience needs to be understood rather than overridden.
A new relationship may need to be different
If reconciliation is something you are considering, perhaps the question isn’t:
“Can I forgive what happened?”
It might be:
“Can we build something different from what we had before?”
That could involve talking honestly about what happened.
It could involve recognising the impact of past behaviour.
It could involve taking responsibility.
It could involve respecting boundaries.
And it may involve rebuilding trust slowly, rather than assuming that because contact has resumed, everything is back to normal.
A new relationship doesn’t have to recreate the old one.
In fact, sometimes the only way forward is for it to be different.
You can remember without remaining stuck in the past
Not forgiving doesn’t necessarily mean holding onto anger forever.
And forgiveness doesn’t necessarily mean that you have forgotten what happened.
You can remember something and still move forward.
You can understand someone’s circumstances without excusing their behaviour.
You can have compassion for someone and still maintain boundaries.
You can decide to have a relationship with someone without deciding that everything that happened between you was acceptable.
There can be space for all of those things at once.
What would reconciliation need to look like for you?
If you’re considering reconnecting, it may be helpful to put forgiveness to one side for a moment and ask some different questions:
What would I need to feel comfortable exploring this relationship?
What would need to be different this time?
What boundaries would I need?
What would rebuilding trust look like?
Do I feel able to say no, slow things down or change my mind?
And perhaps:
Am I reconnecting because I genuinely want to, or because I feel that I should?
You don’t have to answer all of these questions immediately.
Reconciliation can be a process rather than a single decision.
And forgiveness doesn’t have to be the price of admission.
You can acknowledge the past without pretending it didn’t happen.
You can receive an apology without feeling obliged to accept it in a particular way.
And if you do choose to build a new relationship, it can be based on what is possible between you now, rather than requiring you to erase what happened before.
Sometimes moving forward isn’t about forgiving the past.
It’s about understanding it, deciding what you need now, and working out whether a different kind of relationship is possible.
Hello, I’m Sarah Swain, an accredited therapist and coach working online across London, South East, Kent and the whole of the UK. I’ve worked as a therapist across the NHS, charities and Employee Assistance Programmes for over 15 years. I am trained in integrative therapy, coaching and EMDR and I support adults navigating estrangement.
Leave a Reply